African Arguments

Top Menu

  • About Us
  • Submit
  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Newsletter
  • Jobs
  • RSS feed

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Country
    • Central
      • Cameroon
      • Central African Republic
      • Chad
      • Congo-Brazzaville
      • Congo-Kinshasa
      • Equatorial Guinea
      • Gabon
    • East
      • Burundi
      • Comoros
      • Dijbouti
      • Eritrea
      • Ethiopia
      • Kenya
      • Rwanda
      • Seychelles
      • Somalia
      • South Sudan
      • Sudan
      • Tanzania
      • Uganda
      • Red Sea
    • North
      • Algeria
      • Egypt
      • Libya
      • Morocco
      • Tunisia
      • Western Sahara
    • Southern
      • Angola
      • Botswana
      • Lesotho
      • Madagascar
      • Malawi
      • Mauritius
      • Mozambique
      • Namibia
      • South Africa
      • Swaziland
      • Zambia
      • Zimbabwe
    • West
      • Benin
      • Burkina Faso
      • Cape Verde
      • Côte d’Ivoire
      • The Gambia
      • Ghana
      • Guinea
      • Guinea Bissau
      • Liberia
      • Mali
      • Mauritania
      • Niger
      • Nigeria
      • São Tomé and Príncipe
      • Senegal
      • Sierra Leone
      • Togo
  • Politics
    • Elections Map
  • Economy
  • Society
  • Culture
  • Red Sea
  • Insiders Insights
  • Donate
  • About Us
  • Submit
  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Newsletter
  • Jobs
  • RSS feed

logo

Header Banner

African Arguments

  • Home
  • Country
    • Central
      • Cameroon
      • Central African Republic
      • Chad
      • Congo-Brazzaville
      • Congo-Kinshasa
      • Equatorial Guinea
      • Gabon
    • East
      • Burundi
      • Comoros
      • Dijbouti
      • Eritrea
      • Ethiopia
      • Kenya
      • Rwanda
      • Seychelles
      • Somalia
      • South Sudan
      • Sudan
      • Tanzania
      • Uganda
      • Red Sea
    • North
      • Algeria
      • Egypt
      • Libya
      • Morocco
      • Tunisia
      • Western Sahara
    • Southern
      • Angola
      • Botswana
      • Lesotho
      • Madagascar
      • Malawi
      • Mauritius
      • Mozambique
      • Namibia
      • South Africa
      • Swaziland
      • Zambia
      • Zimbabwe
    • West
      • Benin
      • Burkina Faso
      • Cape Verde
      • Côte d’Ivoire
      • The Gambia
      • Ghana
      • Guinea
      • Guinea Bissau
      • Liberia
      • Mali
      • Mauritania
      • Niger
      • Nigeria
      • São Tomé and Príncipe
      • Senegal
      • Sierra Leone
      • Togo
  • Politics
    • Elections Map
  • Economy
  • Society
  • Culture
  • Red Sea
  • Insiders Insights
  • Donate
Politics

Human Security Report: A Major Blow to Humanitarian Accountability

By Les Roberts
January 20, 2010
692
0
Share:

I was sorry to see the Human Security Report (HSR) released today. I was sorry because this report draws unjustified conclusions and will leave the world more ignorant and misguided for its release. There are four very weak aspects of this report that led to this opening line which I find most problematic, “this report reveals that nationwide mortality rates actually fall during most wars”:

1) This and many other conclusions are solely a function of the low threshold chosen to define “war,” considering it to be ongoing with just 25 killings per year. If war was instead defined as occurring in a population where 0.1% was violently killed in a year, I strongly suspect almost all of the HSR conclusions would reverse. This definition would be closer to the public image of war and to where humanitarian aid dollars flow.

2) The report is rife with profound inconsistencies of logic. Moreover, the report completely contradicts a main theme of the last Human Security Report (“War-related diseases kill and disable far more people than bombs and bullets”). The conclusions about giving up on surveys to directly measure war-time excess deaths contradicts the conclusion from the meeting you hosted in March, 2004 with a collection of highly regarded experts including: Jennifer Leaning, Debbi Sapir, and Richard Garfield. Some of the more egregious internal inconsistencies are listed in Appendix B (Appendices available here: Appendices to Les Roberts Critique of HSR).

3) The report is unscholarly, not fully exploring sources, citing one source for one point and ignoring that source elsewhere. It was particularly selective to cite Chris Murray’s 2002 BMJ article as “much-cited” but not the follow-up 2008 BMJ article with Ziad Obermeyer which shows that the PIRO dataset on which the HSR is largely based, misses most deaths. A list of serious inconsistencies or errors is included as Appendix C.

4) The HSR claims war does not stop the usual mortality decline seen in most poor nations, but then does not study or report on those people affected at the times of war. The report looks at entire nations where you admit a tiny fraction of people are affected for a tiny fraction of the study period and draw conclusions with data so crude and general as to be meaningless. The report uses national, time-smoothed data… without the appropriate confidence intervals… to detect the effects of armed conflict. For those of us who were in Rwanda in 1994 and saw those thousands of child bodies dumped in the mass graves, the idea presented in the HSR that 1995 and 1996 were less healthy for children than 1994 is incomprehensible.

As a contributor to the last Human Security Report, I was sorry to see this report. As one of the main forces of accountability in humanitarian assistance, the Canadian Government should be mortified by this report and its, perhaps inadvertent, assault on SMART and relief accountability. As a scientist, I am disheartened to see all this money spent on the HSR to make the academic community more fractious. Many years ago we went out and attempted to report to the world about an unfolding crisis in the Congo. We did it carefully, but as we described at the time, crudely, at great risk to life and limb, and at only a few percent of the cost of this Human Security Report. It is unbecoming to grab a headline a decade after by tearing down a study with erroneous speculation. If the HSR wants to advance this field, there are apparently under-reported crises underway in Somalia and Northern CAR; go there and do better.

Previous Article

Are Wars Becoming Less Lethal? The 2009 ...

Next Article

Can Darfur Claim the Right of Self ...

Les Roberts

Related articles More from author

  • Politics

    Kismayo and the Rise and Fall of a Somali President – By Abdiaziz Abdi

    June 25, 2013
    By African Arguments
  • Politics

    To beat Al Shabaab Kenya must expel its religious leader “˜Sheikh Hassaan’ from Nairobi – By Hassan M. Abukar

    September 25, 2013
    By African Arguments
  • Politics

    Audio: South Sudan’s Bishop Emeritus Paride Taban

    July 27, 2015
    By African Arguments
  • Politics

    Sudan’s Economy and the Financial Crisis

    February 6, 2009
    By Hafiz Mohammed
  • Politics

    Abdullahi Yusuf: A Somali warlord’s life and days – By Mohamed Haji Ingiriis

    August 3, 2012
    By African Arguments
  • Politics

    Congo: Pygmy women leader and environmental activist appointed minister in South Kivu – By Kris Berwouts

    June 5, 2013
    By African Arguments

Leave a reply Cancel reply

  • Politics

    DRC: Kabila eyes lifetime presidency and must be given a way out – By Theophile Costeur

  • PoliticsZambia

    Zambia gears up for unsettlingly close elections

  • In November 2018, Abubakar Shekau appeared in a video for the first time since July.
    NigeriaSocietyTop story

    Is Boko Haram’s notorious leader about to return from the dead again?

Our Newsletters

Interactive Elections Map

Find us on Facebook

Follow us on twitter

  • 62291
    Followers

Most Read

  • Tanzania. Credit: Andrew Moore
    Tanzania search for missing millions raises questions over $1 billion
  • The Volta region first became part of Ghana in 1956. Credit: jbdodane.
    Is this Africa’s newest secession dilemma?
  • France Chad: French and Chad military participate in ceremony to commemorate launch of Operation Barkhane. Credit: Chief Warrant Officer 3 Martin S. Bonner.
    Airstrikes and “stability”: What’s the French army doing in Chad?
  • Protests in Sudan have been ongoing for weeks. Credit: DIGITALAIN.
    Sudan: A genuine, peaceful people’s revolution in the making
  • Liberia court: Hundreds of thousands of people were killed in Liberia's consecutive civil wars. Credit: Mark Fischer.
    “You have to face justice so I can get peace”: Calls for war court in Liberia

About

African Arguments is a pan-African platform for news analysis, comment and opinion. We seek to analyse issues facing the continent, investigate the stories that matter, and amplify a diversity of voices.

Our content is published on a Creative Commons license.

Get in touch

editor@africanarguments.org

Brought to you by


  • Cookies
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
© Copyright African Arguments 2018
By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.