Horn of Africa: Eritrea punches above its weight – by Maddy Fry
The accusations made against Eritrea of plotting to bomb this year’s African Union summit were alarming for many reasons. First and foremost, they illustrate how much the government is willing to draw on other extremist groups in the region to help achieve its aims. The country was accused of planning an attack that would have resulted in the killing of delegates from a wealth of African nations, and this implies their aims have extended to other parts of the Horn, if not to the world at large. Asmara claimed, as always, the accusations were completely fictitious. But among those arrested in connection with the plot was a member of the Ethiopia-based Oromo Liberation Front (OLF), Omar Idriss Mohamed.
By Maddy Fry
Mohamed maintained that those involved sought not to target other African leaders but rather to simply use the Addis-based summit as a way to weaken confidence within the Ethiopian state. While Asmara’s previous activities had been limited to causing direct damage within the borders of its larger neighbour, the plot, if true, suggests even if its aims are unchanged its methods are not. Eritrea is now seeking to tap into wider networks across East Africa in order to further the state’s campaign against Ethiopia – in the process being prepared to harm non-Ethiopian civilians or politicians.
This begs the question as to who exactly was involved in the scheme. The main player alongside Eritrea appears to be the OLF, with the UN suspecting they were even the ones leading the plot under the direction of the aforementioned Mohamed. Those caught were also found in possession of weapons imported from Romania and later on, to have been paid for their participation via conduits stationed in Kenya and Sudan. The “small Red Sea state,” as the Western press so often refers to it, has drastically expanded its sphere of influence.
Formed in 1973, the OLF are in some ways Asmara’s natural bedfellows. They too see themselves pitted in a war against Abyssinian “˜imperialism,’ seeking self-determination for the country’s Oromo-speaking population. Like Eritrea they fought to bring about the downfall of the Derg regime in Addis in 1991, eventually severing their links with Meles Zenawi’s government after accusing it of locking up and killing their members. Unlike Eritrea, the OLF has been wracked by uncertainty over whether or not to fight for an independent Oromia or merely the recognition of Oromo rights within a more tolerant Ethiopian state.
One of the problems hampering Ethiopian unity has been that so many groups within its borders still see the state as maintaining a tradition of fierce imperial dominance involving the oppression of minority groups, despite the ruling party being predominantly Tigrayan – a marked change from the Amharic ethnic dominance of the past. For the formerly subservient Eritrea to form an alliance with the OLF in a joint struggle against its larger neighbour should surprise no-one.
Eritrea-Ethiopian tensions are rooted in a convoluted mix of fall-outs between various rebel groups and self-aggrandising nationalist mythology. To the Western media, Eritrea’s history is nasty, brutish and short. Often summarised in barely a sentence, details rarely include much beyond its former status as an Italian colony in the 1930s before being subsumed by its larger neighbour and eventually gaining independence in 1993.
Unsurprisingly, the picture painted by the ruling independence group, the Eritrean People’s Liberation Front (EPLF, but now the People’s Front for Democracy and Justice or PFDJ) is a rather different one. The liberation struggle they were a part of in the 1980s, led by Isaias Afewerki, espoused a discourse drawn from Eritrea’s past, one it claimed had first been ruptured when the Ethiopian emperor Yohannes extended sovereignty over it in the 1870s, and a fierce sense of self-determination and national identity forged through its ongoing struggles against colonial forces, both European and African. Despite Afewerki’s former close friendship with Meles Zenawi during the Tigrayan People’s Liberation Front’s struggle against the Derg, relations were severed in disputes over border territories between the two countries. As Zenawi went on to lead Ethiopia, a state of violent hostility remained between him and his former comrade. The fact that Eritrea is so often only spoken about in relation to its larger neighbour has therefore only entrenched the country’s anger towards Ethiopia.
Eritrea keeps denying all allegations of violence thrown at it. It’s true that the simplistic faux-Cold War dichotomy the country has been characterised by in the past, particularly regarding its relationship with Ethiopia, is inaccurate. The predominantly Islamic Eritrea is seen by the US and others as being aligned with the East and thus anti-Western, whilst Ethiopia, for all the faults of its present government, is often seen as pro-Western and hence innately progressive. Such broad definitions have rarely stood up to scrutiny given that Eritrea’s priorities of late have lain predominantly with its deteriorating relations with Addis Ababa.
But as new revelations are exposed, the denials are wearing thin. Asmara may have been the main actor behind the AU bomb scare. But given the number of countries it has contacts with its aims are no longer isolated. The “little Red Sea state” is starting to punch above its weight – with potentially fatal consequences.
Maddy Fry is a freelance journalist. She has written for The Daily Telegraph, openDemocracy.net and ThinkAfricaPress.
Eritrea is not predominantly Islamic.
Most reputable stats say that the country is split 50/50 between Christians and Muslims, if not, majority Christian. The ruling party is also characterized by Christian dominance. I think there was obviously a purpose in depicting Eritrea as “Islamic” (while it’s neighbor “western backed” country has just as much an Islamic presence, but is not named so). It’s important that this is corrected, and further bold statements throughout the article are looked over because pretty soon, Eritrea will be called by other major research organizations and news outlets as a “Muslim” country, and then pretty soon an “Arab” country which will of course make the accusations of terrorism much more easily accepted.
It seems the western media and its handlers are having a hard time swallowing another fact about Eritrea-they cannot fathom that there is NO famine in Eritrea, whilst its neighbors, Djibouti, Ethiopia, Kenya and Somalia are all experiencing drought and famine. Instead of congratulating the Government and people of Eritrea for mitigating the effects of recurrent droughts in the region with innovative and sustainable solutions, they have set out, once again, instead, to vilify and undermine this young nation and its magnanimous population. The harshest commentary have come from US officials and the hapless western media in tow, who find it impossible to utter a single kind word on issues related to Eritrea.
Let us take a look at some of the condescending comments:
Â§ â€œâ€¦Because it is a part of the greater Horn of Africa, we assume that conditions in Eritrea are probably quite similar to the drought conditions that we are seeing in other places â€“ in Ethiopia, Kenya, Djibouti and Somalia. Because we donâ€™t know whatâ€™s happening, our understanding of the situation is limited, but we encourage them to be more open about their needs and the needs of their populationâ€¦â€-(Johnnie Carson, US Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs, 19 July 2011)
Â§ â€œâ€¦Eritrea, a nation of 5 million people that borders Sudan, Ethiopia and Djibouti, has also seen failed rains and widespread food shortagesâ€¦refuses to acknowledge a drought has swept its territory. Satellite images show that the Red Sea nation has been hit by drought conditions similar to those in Somalia, Ethiopia and Djiboutiâ€¦â€ â€“(LUC VAN KEMENADE, AFP 28 July 2011 â€œ E.Africa faces famine, Eritrea suffers in silenceâ€)
Â§ We believe there is a famine in Eritrea, but weâ€™re deeply concerned that none of us know because they have barred UN agencies, barred NGOs. It has become a black hole in terms of governance and humanitarian ground truth. And the people of Eritrea, who mustâ€¦most likely are suffering the very same food shortages that weâ€™re seeing throughout the region are being left to starve because there is not access, thereâ€™s a clear cut denial of access by the government of Eritrea of food and other humanitarian support for its people. â€“(Susan E. Rice, US Ambassador to the UN 11 August 2011)
But not all â€œdiplomatsâ€™ are as vindictive. To his credit, H.E. Klaus Peter Schick, German Ambassador to Eritrea is not going along with the â€œfamine in Eritreaâ€ propaganda. Neither are ordinary citizens who are fed up with the constant abuse against Eritrea and its government.
Steve Kirkland, a Canadian citizen, responding to a recent article about famine in Eritrea and statements made by Johnnie Carson, the incompetent and vindictive US Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs, wrote the following on 23 July 2011:
â€œâ€¦Commenting as a non-partisan (Canadian) observer, I fully admire the independent stance the Eritrean people have taken in the face of adversity and vilification from much of the international community (much of it through sheer ignorance, in my humble opinion). For the last 3 months, I was in Eritrea and I can attest that there is no food shortages or food insecurities taking place. No one was saying anything as Eritrea went an entire year and half without food aid in 2010, all of a sudden, since Ethiopia starts begging the international community to feed their people, that Eritrea too must be starving? This is racist and condescending, as it assumes because Eritreaâ€™s neighbors have failed and continue to fail that Eritrea too must fail. This is nuts and itâ€™s politically motivated. This type of racist tones coming from Jonnie Carson is geared for ignorant readers in North Americaâ€¦.If Eritrea is a â€œsecretiveâ€ nation (as so the narrative goes to sell newspapers these days), then they do a pretty bad job with it because there are thousands of Europeans who live in Eritrea and tens of thousands of Eritrean nationals from the diaspora who visit throughout the yearâ€¦Iâ€™m 38 years old, Iâ€™m an electrician, Canadian (caucasian) and I can attest thereâ€™s no food shortage or hunger taking place within Eritrea. In fact, after being in Eritrea 3 months and seeing what Iâ€™ve seen, I think other African nation should follow the Eritrean example and start to feed their population with their own capacity. When did feeding yourself become tantamount to unjust and a human rights abuse? This is racist to the highest degree and Jonnie Carson and his U.S. administration should be ashamed of themselvesâ€¦â€
The contempt and hatred that Johnnie Carson and Susan E. Rice, the US Ambassador to the United Nations harbor against the Government and people of Eritrea prevents them from making sound or prudent judgments about issues in the Horn of Africa.
The Eritrean Quislings League (EQL), a hodge podge collection of individuals with dubious and criminal backgrounds, runaway defectors, disgruntled ex-diplomats, pedophiles etc. etc. are today acting as if they are concerned about the very people they worked so hard to starve in to submission. It should be recalled that they, like the minority regime in Ethiopia, have campaigned to isolate Eritrea diplomatically and politically and have been calling for cuts in development and humanitarian aid to Eritrea for the last 12 years.
In 2002-2003, when the US-led international community decided to deprive the people of Eritrea food aid, the Government of Eritrea went out in the open market and bought over 300000 tonnes of food to feed the people, whilst the minority regime in Ethiopia was provided with plane loads of food aid to feed starving Ethiopians. Thanks to a sound food security policy and a hardworking population, Eritrea is faring better than its neighbors this year. Today, not only is rain pouring in Eritreaâ€¦there were some places in Asmara, the capital, which saw snow for the very first time. That means the hundreds of dams, micro-dams, reservoirs, and wells will accumulate more water. Divine interventionâ€¦But let us get back to more of the misinformation and anti-Eritrea reports.
On 19 August 2011, there were two conflicting reports from the Washington Post about the famine in the Horn of Africa region. The first report (Associated Press, Updated: Friday, August 19, 4:49 PM) said the following:
â€œâ€¦UNITED NATIONS â€” The head of the U.N. childrenâ€™s agency says more than 300,000 children in the Horn of Africa are severely malnourished â€œand in imminent risk of dyingâ€ because of drought and famineâ€¦The U.N. says tens of thousands of people already have died in Somalia, Kenya, Ethiopia, Djibouti and Eritrea and that more than 12 million people in the region need food aidâ€¦â€
But just about an hour later, the Washington Post story had changed. Under the same headline, the second report (Associated Press, Updated: Friday, August 19, 5:53 PM) reported the following:
â€œâ€¦The United Nations says tens of thousands of people already have died in Somalia, Kenya, Ethiopia and Djibouti and has warned that the famine hasnâ€™t peaked. More than 12 million people in the region need food aid, according to the U.Nâ€¦â€
This time, Eritrea was dropped from the list.
Not sure if UNICEF was weighing its statements carefully or if it was responding to the many complaints by Eritreans who are fed up with this lazy â€œcut and pasteâ€ reporting that has been used to malign and vilify the Government and people of Eritrea for the last 12 years. In any case, the western media can do its readers a favor and refrain from such deliberate and malicious yellow journalism. Speaking of malicious reportingâ€¦allow me to address one that is related to â€œfamine in Eritreaâ€.
Most of us have read the Wikileak cables that were authored by Ambassdor Ronald McMullen, former US Ambassador to Eritrea. I donâ€™t want to go into those scandalous cables just yet, but since we are talking about famine, there was one cable that mentioned famine and Eritrea. It was entitled, â€œISAIAS ADMITS FAMINE PRESENT IN ERITREA; PROMISES UNICEF ACCESSâ€, and it was authored by CDA Melinda Tabler-Stone on 20 November 2009. In it, she writes:
â€œâ€¦In a surprising departure from his public pronouncements on the non-existence of hunger in Eritrea, President Isaias admitted to visiting UNICEF Deputy Executive Director Hilde Johnson that there is famine in the country and UNICEFÂ´s help is needed. Johnson briefed Western diplomats on her November 17-18 visit to Eritrea and her lengthy meeting with Isaias. She said Isaias promised UNICEF total access to the country for the purposes of conducting a nutrition survey and providing blanket supplementary feedingâ€¦â€
When I read that cable, I had a few questions for UNICEF and Ms. Johnson. On 7 July 2011, I enquired the following of UNICEF. I wrote:
â€œâ€¦There is a Wikileaks document that mentions Ms. Hilde Johnson and her visit to Eritrea in 2009 and her meeting with President Isaias Afwerki. Is it true that he told her that there was famine in Eritrea? Did Eritrea ask for food aid? Were there any deaths? What about malnutrition in Eritrea? Did she visit any villages and hospitals while she was there? What did she see? I hope she can get back to me as soon as possibleâ€¦â€
A few days later I received a response and it said:
â€œâ€¦Thank you for your inquiry. This is to inform you that your e-mail has been forwarded to Ms. Johnson’s office. She will reply at her discretionâ€¦â€
I am still waiting for Ms. Johnsonâ€™s replyâ€¦
But not all enquiries end up empty. Allow me to explain.
There was a 4 August 2011 article entitled, â€œPHOTO STORY: Drought and water shortages stalk Eritrea’s refugee campsâ€ by Matilde Gattoni posted on the ecologist website, part of the Guardian Environmental Network. In addition to some disturbing pictures, that article said that:
â€œâ€¦The situation has been exacerbated by the unresolved border dispute, resulting in economic stagnation, lack of food security and increased susceptibility of the population to various ailments including communicable diseases and malnutritionâ€¦â€
On 5 August 2011 I wrote to Matilda Gattoni and asked the following questions:
â€œâ€¦When were you last in Eritrea and when were the pictures taken… Where in Eritrea did you find these “IDP camps”â€¦You state in your piece that “…These IDPs have fled three times in the last 10 years, each time because of renewed military conflict… Currently there is no Ethiopian occupation in Eritrea…Please tell me when the three conflicts took place, who were they with and I also want to know how you would explain the continued Ethiopian military presence in Badme and other sovereign Eritrean territories. If that is not occupation, what exactly you call it?…â€
Imagine my surprise when Ms. Gattoni responded almost immediately to my email enquiry, saying the following:
â€œâ€¦I did not write the article, I’m a photographer â€¦â€
I off course was not about to let it go so I asked her who wrote the article if she hadnâ€™t. She responded by saying:
â€œâ€¦God knows, get in touch with the magazine. You are not the first person telling me this, I have given them a few notes from the UN as I went with them in 2003, I am not a journalist but a photographer, they added a lot of stuff and I was not even aware it was published yet. Anyway to answer one of your questions I went there in 2003 and travelled a bit everywhere but mainly focused on a camp which was located next to the Ethiopian border. I forgot the name nowâ€¦â€
While continuing my conversation with Ms. Gattoni on the one hand, I decided to write to the entire staff of the online magazine (with the hopes that at least one of them would bother to respond). After telling them that I had contacted Ms. Gattoni and she had told me that she was not the author of the said article, I said:
â€œâ€¦Unless you can give me a plausible reason why and how such an article could find its way to your site, I have no choice but to believe that this is yet another desperate attempt to undermine the Government and people of Eritrea and their development effortsâ€¦Instead of applauding their success in building a sustainable, environmentally sound food security infrastructure, Eritrea has been unduly maligned for not stretching her arms and begging for food as the Ethiopians haveâ€¦Instead of fabricating a story, why not go to Eritrea and see for yourselves…it would help your credibility and integrityâ€¦â€
On that day, I received an automated response from all the addressees saying they were out of the office. It was going to be a long weekend.
On 8 August 2011, I got a response from one of the addressees and he said:
â€œâ€¦Thanks for your correspondence re: this story which has gone to several staff at the Ecologistâ€¦Whilst I look into the details surrounding the story I’ve removed it from the magazine websiteâ€¦â€
I waited for about one day and checked to see if the article had really been removed. It didnâ€™t look like it was, so I wrote to him again and his response was:
â€œâ€¦The story has been removed from the site – is possible cached versions are still visable but it’s no longer on the homepage or news sections, and the Facebook link has been taken down…â€
He was right, but it took an entire weekend and some, to get this false story removed. God knows how many false stories were borne out of that story since. One question that remained unanswered is why? Why would anyone stoop so low as to bring a 7 year old story to make a case against Eritrea? To me, this is sheer desperation on the part of Eritreaâ€™s enemies who cannot stand to hear any good news coming from Eritrea. These prophets of gloom and doom have their work cut out for themâ€¦
There are reasons why the people of Eritrea are not in need of food aid today. Eritrea has a sound and visionary food security strategy that is working. Ensuring food security is one of the top national priorities and the cornerstone for sustainable economic growth and poverty reduction strategy in Eritrea. Introduced in 2004, Eritreaâ€™s food security strategy has two dimensions, a national food security strategy and a household food security strategy.
1. National Food Security: Food is available in market throughout the country from domestic production, commercial imports, or food assistance. The strategy for achieving national food security objectives rests on three pillars:
a. Enhancing the domestic food production capacity;
b. Increasing national capacity to import an adequate quantity of food supply;
c. Enhancing the effective use of food assistance to fill the supply gap during emergencies.
2. Household Food Security: All household members have affordable access at all times to the food they need for a healthy life. Objectives rest on three pillars:
a. Enhancing the Productive Capacity of Small Scale Farmers
b. Enhancing Household Purchasing Power
c. Public Assistance Programs Targeted at the Poor & Vulnerable
The Government of Eritrea has invested tens of millions in modern agricultural equipment and introducing modern farming techniques such as drip water irrigation, and has promoted the use of modern farming practices-primarily farm inputs (increasing fertilizer use, pesticides), use of improved pest control and reducing post-harvest losses.
It has provided support for constructing hand-dug wells, reservoirs, pump houses, ventilated storerooms, and secondary earthen canals, purchased and installed motor pumps, generators, and pipes, prepared and cleared land, trained farmers in irrigation and appropriate farming methodologies; and provided seeds, fertilizer, chemicals and farm tools etc. etc.
The Government has also encouraged commercial farming, by introducing industrial crops, promoting the use of tube wells, and construction of micro -dams and small water storage facilities throughout the country etc. etc. Obviously, all this hard work and commitment has not been for naught. Today, the people of Eritrea are reaping the fruits of their hard work and sacrifice. Young and old, men and women have partnered with members of Eritreaâ€™s Defense Forces to rehabilitate and develop Eritreaâ€™s agricultural infrastructures which have had a huge impact on food security in Eritrea.
Johnnie Carson and Susan E. Rice can go right ahead and shed crocodile tears for Eritrea, but their concerns are misplaced. They both know, more than anyone else, that the real tears should be shed for the people of Ethiopia who have to live under a brutal dictatorship led by Meles Zenawi, leader of the minority regime in Ethiopia. There is NO famine in Eritrea and they better come to terms with that bitter fact. Today, Eritrea is NOT one of the countries that is suffering from famine or drought and any reports that purport to say otherwise ought to be considered malicious and self serving.
Finally, if there is anyone out there that has contacts with UNICEF, please let them know that I am still waiting for a response. I just want to know if what CDA Melinda Tabler-Stone wrote in the cable was exactly what Ms. Johnson had told the diplomatic community in Asmara, or if CDA Melinda Tabler-Stone had added a little flavor to spice up the otherwise boring gossip-like â€œdiplomaticâ€ cableâ€¦
The rule of law will prevail over the law of the jungle!
By Thomas C. Mountain,
Recently released Wikileaks Ethiopia files expose how Ethiopian security forces planted 3 bombs that went off in the Ethiopian capital Addis Ababa on September 16, 2006 and then blamed Eritrea and the Oromo resistance for the blasts in a case that raises serious questions about the claims made about the bombing attempt against the African Union summit earlier this year in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
In a report from 2006 marked â€œSecret ; Subject: Ethiopia: Recent Bombings Blamed on Oromos Possibly the Work of GOE [Government of Ethiopia]â€¦by: Charge [dâ€™Affairs] Vicki Huddlestonâ€, â€œAn embassy source, as well as clandestine reporting, suggests that the bombing may have in fact been the work of the GoE security forces.â€ Cable reference id: #06ADDISABABA2708
At the time the western media reported the Ethiopian National Intelligence and Security Service (NISS) claims that the bombs were â€œpart of a coordinated terror attack by the OLF [Oromo Liberation Front, the oldest national liberation movement in Ethiopia] and Shaebia (Eritrea) aimed at disrupting democratic developmentâ€.
The Wikileaks report goes on, â€œa typically reliable information source contacted Post to report thatâ€ the bodies of three men found at the bomb sites were â€œmen [who] had been picked up by police a week prior, kept in detention and tortured. He said police then left the men in a house and detonated explosives nearby, killing 3 of them.â€
This exposes the history of how the Ethiopian regime has planted bombs and then blamed Eritrea and the Ethiopian resistance. The lies that make up the official version of this alleged terrorist attack raises serious questions about the credibility of the recently released report by the UN via its US State Department affiliate, the Monitoring Group for Eritrea and Somalia which blames the Eritreans and the OLF for the January bombing attempt at the African Union summit in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Identical lies about a nearly identical â€œterrorist attackâ€, all accepted as fact by the western media. This should also deliver another body blow to the Obama White House and its claims that Eritrea supports terrorism in the Horn of Africa.
So once again the bellowing against Eritrea by the USA and it lackeys at the UN going back to 2006 is exposed as complete bunkum and an identical frame up of Eritrean and the Oromo resistance in Ethiopia that has been regurgitated by the UN and its truth challenged Monitoring Group on Eritrea and Somalia must be subject to a more critical scrutiny. Based on this exposeâ€™ it can only be hoped that the UN inSecurity Council, which has yet to decide whether to pass severe sanctions against Eritrea, will refrain from doing so.