African Arguments

Top Menu

  • About Us
  • Write for us
  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Newsletter
  • RSS feed
  • Donate
  • Fellowship

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Country
    • Central
      • Cameroon
      • Central African Republic
      • Chad
      • Congo-Brazzaville
      • Congo-Kinshasa
      • Equatorial Guinea
      • Gabon
    • East
      • Burundi
      • Comoros
      • Dijbouti
      • Eritrea
      • Ethiopia
      • Kenya
      • Rwanda
      • Seychelles
      • Somalia
      • Somaliland
      • South Sudan
      • Sudan
      • Tanzania
      • Uganda
      • Red Sea
    • North
      • Algeria
      • Egypt
      • Libya
      • Morocco
      • Tunisia
      • Western Sahara
    • Southern
      • Angola
      • Botswana
      • eSwatini
      • Lesotho
      • Madagascar
      • Malawi
      • Mauritius
      • Mozambique
      • Namibia
      • South Africa
      • Zambia
      • Zimbabwe
    • West
      • Benin
      • Burkina Faso
      • Cape Verde
      • Côte d’Ivoire
      • The Gambia
      • Ghana
      • Guinea
      • Guinea Bissau
      • Liberia
      • Mali
      • Mauritania
      • Niger
      • Nigeria
      • São Tomé and Príncipe
      • Senegal
      • Sierra Leone
      • Togo
  • Politics
    • Elections Map
  • Economy
  • Society
    • Climate crisis
  • Culture
  • Specials
    • From the fellows
    • Radical Activism in Africa
    • On Food Security & COVID19
    • #EndSARS
    • Covid-19
    • Travelling While African
    • From the wit-hole countries…
    • Living in Translation
    • Red Sea
    • Beautiful Game
  • Podcast
    • Into Africa Podcast
    • Africa Science Focus Podcast
    • Think African Podcast
  • Debating Ideas
  • About Us
  • Write for us
  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Newsletter
  • RSS feed
  • Donate
  • Fellowship

logo

Header Banner

African Arguments

  • Home
  • Country
    • Central
      • Cameroon
      • Central African Republic
      • Chad
      • Congo-Brazzaville
      • Congo-Kinshasa
      • Equatorial Guinea
      • Gabon
    • East
      • Burundi
      • Comoros
      • Dijbouti
      • Eritrea
      • Ethiopia
      • Kenya
      • Rwanda
      • Seychelles
      • Somalia
      • Somaliland
      • South Sudan
      • Sudan
      • Tanzania
      • Uganda
      • Red Sea
    • North
      • Algeria
      • Egypt
      • Libya
      • Morocco
      • Tunisia
      • Western Sahara
    • Southern
      • Angola
      • Botswana
      • eSwatini
      • Lesotho
      • Madagascar
      • Malawi
      • Mauritius
      • Mozambique
      • Namibia
      • South Africa
      • Zambia
      • Zimbabwe
    • West
      • Benin
      • Burkina Faso
      • Cape Verde
      • Côte d’Ivoire
      • The Gambia
      • Ghana
      • Guinea
      • Guinea Bissau
      • Liberia
      • Mali
      • Mauritania
      • Niger
      • Nigeria
      • São Tomé and Príncipe
      • Senegal
      • Sierra Leone
      • Togo
  • Politics
    • Elections Map
  • Economy
  • Society
    • Climate crisis
  • Culture
  • Specials
    • From the fellows
    • Radical Activism in Africa
    • On Food Security & COVID19
    • #EndSARS
    • Covid-19
    • Travelling While African
    • From the wit-hole countries…
    • Living in Translation
    • Red Sea
    • Beautiful Game
  • Podcast
    • Into Africa Podcast
    • Africa Science Focus Podcast
    • Think African Podcast
  • Debating Ideas
Editor's PicksSocietySouth Africa

In South Africa, a trans inmate fought the state in court. And won.

By Nigel Patel
October 2, 2019
3067
0
Share:

A ground-breaking ruling in favour of a trans inmate challenges South Africa’s discriminatory status quo. 

Protesters show their support at Jade September’s court ruling. Credit: Gender DynamiX

On the 23rd of September, the South African Equality Court handed down a judgment in favour of Jade September, an incarcerated transgender woman and sex worker. The Court held that the respondents from the State’s Department of Correctional Services had unfairly discriminated against September by not allowing her to express her gender identity. 

September was sentenced to prison for 15 years after being convicted of murder, theft and attempted theft of a motor vehicle. Serving part of this sentence in spaces designated for males, September was harassed by prison officials for being transgender and prevented from expressing her gender. She was forced to cut her hair and prohibited from wearing make-up, jewellery and gender-affirming underwear. Prison staff refused to address September as a woman and use she/her pronouns. She was also placed in segregated confinement as punishment for her behaviour.

In response, September took the matter to court. Represented by Lawyers for Human Rights, she made the case that “her gender identity is the core and the essence of who she is as a human being”. Her team argued that her treatment in prison amounted to unfair discrimination and that her rights – according to the South African Constitution, international law, and foreign and domestic judgments – had been violated. 

Defending the Department of Correctional Services, the State argued that September had been treated appropriately as an inmate who is anatomically and legally male. It was further argued that if September had been discriminated against, those actions had not been unfair. The State contended that any limitations placed on her rights were for her own safety as expressing “herself as a female, would expose the applicant to sexual violence”. The lawyers also disputed the claim September had been placed in segregated confinement for asserting her gender. They maintained that she was punished in response to her aggressive behaviour after her make-up was confiscated.

Gender DynamiX, an organisation that deals with trans and gender diverse people’s rights, was also a party to the proceedings. Represented by the Legal Resource Center, its submissions situated the matter in a broader socio-economic context. 

“The legal gender recognition of trans and gender diverse people is often set in a binary and medicalised,” said Liberty Matthyse, executive director of Gender DynamiX. She pointed out that “surgical or medical treatment” is required to change one’s gender market and that “gender affirming health care in South Africa is largely inaccessible to a large part of the trans and gender diverse population.”

Indeed, private gender affirming surgery is costly and often not covered by medical aid. Furthermore, the current waiting list for this surgery in government hospitals is roughly 25 years. These factors contextualise why September, who wants to transition medically, has not yet been able to access the necessary medical care and is still legally recognised as male.  

Trans and gender diverse people in South Africa face high levels of discrimination in many other ways despite South Africa’s inclusive laws and policies on paper. Discrimination in schools and work places results in low levels of formal education and employment. Meanwhile, social stigma often leads to family rejection and homelessness. 

The ruling

Ten months after September’s case was heard, Judge Chantal Fortuin ruled largely in favour of the applicant. While the court found that September’s placement in segregation was related to her belligerent behaviour and therefore not discriminatory, it was critical of the prison’s other actions. It rejected the State’s argument that September was being prevented from expressing her gender for her own protection and said that there were less restrictive means to keep the inmate safe. The judge ruled that the respondents’ failure to allow September to express her gender identity was “manifestly unfair”. 

The Court declared the prison’s operating procedures that prevent transgender inmates from expressing their gender to be unconstitutional. It ordered that September be allowed to express her gender in prison and be addressed as a woman. The judge also provided an option for September to be transferred to a prison space designated for females. 

To help bridge the gap between inclusive policy and its realisation in practice, the Court further ordered that all employees of the Department of Correctional Services undergo mandatory transgender sensitivity training.  This instruction was received with joy and celebration by the many trans and gender diverse people who filled the courtroom in support of September. 

“Its implications are broader”

The momentous ruling affirmed that trans rights and prisoners’ rights are human rights and is a step in the right direction. An ethical government that purports to have a strong human rights culture must ensure its prisoners are not subjected to cruel and torturous punishment. This was highlighted in the judgment’s opening Dostoyevsky quote that “a society should be judged not by how it treats its outstanding citizens, but by how it treats its criminals.”. 

The judgment is a ground-breaking moment in the development of an inclusive legal system that accounts for the spectrum of trans people’s lives. 

“Even though this case was about trans rights in prison, its implications are broader,” commented Sanja Bornman, an attorney from Lawyers for Human Rights who worked on this case. “The recognition of trans people’s constitutional rights requires that every single state service such as shelters, hospitals, clinics, home affairs, and schools have in place policies and practices that are inclusive of trans people.” 

The ruling and the fact it allowed the option of September being transferred to a prison designated for females emphasises South Africa’s legal duty to reasonably accommodate gendered difference. The gendered self is ever changing and a legal remedy that may work for one trans person may not work for another. The flexible approach to gender shown by the court pushes the law and society to progress beyond the idea that gender exists in a fixed binary solely determined by the sex that one is assigned at birth. Its ruling emphasises that institutions and individuals are responsible for expanding space to allow for gender self-identification. 

The judgment also crucially offers LGBTQI+ Africans an emboldening story of a black trans woman’s resilience in the face of systemic discrimination.  

Previous Article

Africa Insiders: Behind Nigeria’s Islamic school “torture ...

Next Article

Angola’s oil could actually be the DR ...

mm

Nigel Patel

Nigel Patel is a philosophy and law graduate and a queer rights activist.

Leave a reply Cancel reply

  • PoliticsZimbabwe

    Fed up, unafraid, and just getting started: What Zimbabwe’s #ThisFlag must do now

  • Malawi lockdown protests coronavirus
    Covid-19MalawiPolitics

    Of protests and polls: Malawi’s very political pandemic

  • At a banana market in Kenya. Credit: CIAT.
    BeninMalawiSociety

    Africa’s battle against malnutrition can be won. These 4 principles will help.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Click here to subscribe to our free weekly newsletter and never miss a thing!

  • 81664
    Followers

Find us on Facebook

Interactive Elections Map

Keep up to date with all the African elections.

Popular articles

  • Have you seen Dakan, the Guinean queer classic? It changed my life.

  • The climate crisis has made weather patterns more extreme and unpredictable in northern Cameroon. Credit: Carsten ten Brink.

    The climate crisis tinderbox in northern Cameroon

  • Credit: Matt Haney/Global Press Journal.

    “Machete wielders” are terrorising parts of Uganda. But why?

  • President Cyril Ramaphosa (left) with his predecessor, former President Jacob Zuma in 2017. Credit: GCIS.

    What did we learn from South Africa’s exhaustive state capture commission?

  • Girls line up during a basketball drill in Mogadishu, Somalia. Credit: AU UN IST/Tobin Jones.

    To counter al-Shabaab, Somalia’s new govt must do something for the kids

Brought to you by


Creative Commons

Creative Commons Licence
Articles on African Arguments are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
  • Cookies
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • en English
    am Amharicar Arabicny Chichewazh-CN Chinese (Simplified)en Englishfr Frenchde Germanha Hausait Italianpt Portuguesest Sesothosn Shonaes Spanishsw Swahilixh Xhosayo Yorubazu Zulu
© Copyright African Arguments 2020
Cleantalk Pixel
By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.
en English
am Amharicar Arabicny Chichewazh-CN Chinese (Simplified)en Englishfr Frenchde Germanha Hausait Italianpt Portuguesest Sesothosn Shonaes Spanishsw Swahilixh Xhosayo Yorubazu Zulu
African Arguments wants to hear from you!

Take 5 minutes to fill in this short reader survey and you could win three African Arguments books of your choice…as well as our eternal gratitude.